Re: Check out our Articles in TFH! It really is interesting to see how varied people's approaches can be. It's hard to fault a persons ideas or techniques if they produce the desired results for them. The real issue is usually that we're not comparing apples to apples. There are so many variables in the hobby that it's almost impossible to do this accurately. TexGal is right. Like coyotes and elephants, many of our plants will grow and thrive under a wide variety of conditions. In the wild they have to.
IME, most issues arise from either too much light or too little light. Sadly, this is the single parameter that is hardest to accurately quantify in our setups. Too much light tends to be the worst problem because it demands very precise and consistent fertilizing strategies. Honestly, some of my favorite tanks are with reasonably easy species in low-tech type setups. They're just so stable.
My biggest issue with some of what TFH has published in the past is that their ideas have been presented as the gospel truth, without proof of concept. Not every hammer will work with every nail. It's good to get some exposure in an international magazine though, n'est-ce pas? As long as there is a place for honest and thought-provoking debate (like forums) we'll continue to progress in our understanding of the hobby. |