JeffB

Hi from Long Island!

This is my first canister purchase. I recently set up a 29 planted tank (my first) with a HOB filter (Penguin with bio wheel), DIY CO2 and a Plant Gro Bubble Counter Diffuser. The tank is moderately planted. I am considering the Eheim 2224 or the Rena X2. Is this overkill for a 29 gal tank. I plan to replace the diffuser with a DIY reactor in line between the canister and the tank. (Get rid of the surface turbulence and increase my CO2 level) The price of the X2 is very tempting, but the decibel lever and longevity (reputation) of the Eheim might well tip the scale. Will I be blowing my plants out of the substrate or should I go with the 2222 instead.

Thanks in advance for all your help
Jeff B