mark77ap

Hi,

I have been doseing EI for about 1 year now. I seem to constantly be battling algae of some sort. I figured I would try this PPS-PRO. It sounds much easier and I like the idea of not having excess nutrients in the water.

With EI, I never dosed Magnesium or Calcium. My Tap water is 22 dGH and 11 dKH. Should I sill add the Ca and Mg to the formula for PPS-PRO? Will it raise my hardness. I have to pump in loads of co2 as it is

Thanks

Mark

 

To avoid seeing this ad in our forum please register at AquaticPlantCentral.com By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features.

hoppycalif

If you use a municipal water company tap water you can get a copy of their water quality report, which usually lists both the calcium and magnesium in the water - almost always a range of values that may be found. If that shows you have some magnesium, around 1/4 of the ppm of the Calcium more or less, I don't see where you need either calcium or magnesium. But, if the report shows little or no magnesium then adding it is a good idea.

mark77ap

Thanks. I do have a copy of the report but it only states the hardeness as 328 mg/L (23 grains). It does not sepcify Calcium or Magnesium individually.

hoppycalif

With water that hard I find it difficult to believe you could be short of magnesium. But, others (Edward?) may differ.

ray-the-pilot

Municipal water suppliers are not required to report water hardness; although many do as a curtesy to their customers.

It is impossible to know the ratio of Ca/Mg from the total hardness; however, with such hard water there is probably enough Mg.

If your not strapped for cash you can get a total/Ca/Mg hardness test kit from LaMotte. It’s like $60 with shipping.
If you can do chemistry you can modify the Red Sea salt water Ca kit to test fresh water by using a larger sample (50 – 200 ml). I could not get the Red Sea kit Mg kit to work on Fresh water.

Bert H

Do not assume a high gh indicates you have enough or the proper ratio of Ca/Mg. If the water source is from a limestone aquifer, chances are you will have tons of Ca, and little Mg. I have well water, gh12-13, from a limestone aquifer, and I add Mg to all my tanks. If I don't I get lots more stunted growth on certain stem plants.

hoppycalif

Bert, that's a good point. I grew up in Missouri, where the "limestone" is actually a mix of calcium and magnesium based rocks, so the water had both. But, I understand that Florida is largely a pure limestone state.

 

To avoid seeing this ad in our forum please register at AquaticPlantCentral.com By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features.