CO2/KH Relationship and pH Monitor/Controller Accuracy

1798 Views 8 Replies 4 Participants Last post by Edward, Jan 2, 2005

trc_pdx

Discussion Starter · Dec 31, 2004

Consider the range of CO2 levels (ppm) at these KH/ph combinations (based on Chuck Gadd's calculator http://www.csd.net/~cgadd/aqua/art_plant_co2chart.htm) :

When KH = 4 and
pH = 6.6 then CO2 = 38
pH = 6.8 then CO2 = 24
ph = 7.0 then CO2 = 15

or

When KH = 5 and
pH = 6.6 then CO2 = 30
pH = 6.8 then CO2 = 19
ph = 7.0 then CO2 = 12

Now, assume you're using the Milwaukee SMS122 pH controller with a stated accuracy of +/- 0.2 pH units.

I take that to mean a reading/set point of 6.8 could actually be as low as 6.6 or as high as 7.0. Is that a correct assumption?

If so, you can see the wide range of resulting CO2 levels at the given KH. With a KH of 4, you could have a CO2 levels ranging from 15 (maybe not high enough for plants) to 38 (perhaps too high for fish?)

Am I missing something or is that the way it would work?

Tim

Save

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

Edward

· #2 · Dec 31, 2004

Hi trc_pdx,

you didn't read the table correctly, but that's not the issue here.
The second part, about the regulator accuracy is correct. This is why we should keep the CO2 30 - 40 ppm. I use 60 ppm with Cardinals, no problem.

Edward

Save

trc_pdx

Discussion Starter · #3 · Jan 1, 2005

Thanks Edward. Yes, I have the 4.0 and 5.0 KH values swapped. I wonder if others have found the frequently cited warnings about CO2 levels above 30 being harmful (to fish) to be erroneous.

Tim

Save

Edward

· #4 · Jan 1, 2005

Hi trc_pdx,

had CO2 at 70 - 90 ppm with Tetras. Nothing was wrong, they were ok.

Edward

Save

trc_pdx

Discussion Starter · #5 · Jan 1, 2005

had CO2 at 70 - 90 ppm with Tetras. Nothing was wrong, they were ok

Wow. The Gadd calculator warns you off at 25ppm.

This probably belongs in the Equipment forum but I wonder if other users of the Milwaukee controller have found it more or less accurate than the specified +/- 0.2 accuracy.

Tim

Save

Raul-7

· #6 · Jan 1, 2005

Edward, you had 70-90ppm without any surface movement what-so-ever? I'm guessing you don't have shrimp either..?

Save

Edward

· #7 · Jan 1, 2005

Hi,

I don't have any shrimps and I always have an air stone running with fish.

Edward

Save

chiahead

· #8 · Jan 1, 2005

Edward you use an airstone in your planted tanks? Doesnt that drive your CO2 off? I have always been told not to use an airstone with pressurized CO2.

Save

Edward

· #9 · Jan 2, 2005

Hi chiahead,

All my tanks with fish have air stones, regulated to low flow.

Save

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.

Top Contributors this Month