Aquatic Plant Forum banner

1 - 20 of 97 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Ok... I'm lazy. Super lazy. I wanted to be able to fertilize daily without actually FERTILIZING daily, ya know? So some people here in the past talked about using peristaltic pumps with timers but I haven't seen anyone actually slap together a working system and post... so I'll do it! I'll first go through a run-down of my materials...

6 peristaltic pumps from www.aptinstruments.com. I used the OEM SP100 pumps (18rpm) w/ 1.6mm norprene tubing (about 0.9ml/min flow). i wanted to be able to dose up to 6 different wet ferts, so i bought six. wanna do 3? buy 3.

for the controllers, i got lazy... i picked up a bunch of table lamp digital timers off amazon.com. they were about 12 bucks a piece and have batteries in case of brief power outages. i put one timer on each pump so i could run them independently. if you are good and know what ratios you need to dose, you can get away with fewer. i went for maximum flexibility (at a much greater expense, though). the timers do an OK job. they have 2 "events" so you can even choose to dose twice a day if you'd like. in addition, you can easily turn them "on" for a few minutes manually if you want to dose something in particular.
http://www.amazon.com/Intermatic-TB...ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1234121541&sr=8-1

i also ordered about 50 feet of norprene tubing from APT as well. in addition, i picked up a few 90 degree elbow connectors so i could make the tube "hook" over the lip of the aquarium.

i have a prototype shop at work, so i whipped up a small "stand" to hold the reservoirs and the pumps are attached above. you can make this out of wood, metal, plastic, WHATEVER. it is not important at all. i used 1/2 gallon milk jugs (cleaned thoroughly) because they are tall and skinny so i could squeeze them in under my stand nicely.

as you can see, each side has 3 jugs and 3 pumps. the desktop lamp timers are nice because the "controller" portion has a cord that runs back to the power strip, so i could mount everything on the door.

so far, i've been running the pumps for about 1 month and i'm very happy. i keep slowly upping the time because i think there is a lot of backpressure so 0.9ml/min isn't what the flow seems to be. something less than that. but since everything is controlled independently, i can just increase whatever i need to increase. i can easily see what ferts are running low. i just used a label maker to clearly label everything. i spray-painted the "stand" black just so i didn't have to look at the bare metal (plus i'm avoiding rust).

oh, the only downside to the lamp timers is that they aren't grouned, so you should probably ground the pumps (mine were not grounded at the time i took these pictures).

it's not perfect, pretty, or sexy... but it works! you have no idea how nice it is just knowing that my ferts get dumped in every morning before the lights go on. and the 1/2 gallon jugs hold quite a lot of ferts... so i don't have to fill them very often. the ultimate in low maintenance!

and to avoid contamination, the output tubes are NOT in contact with the water. the output tubes bend over the lip of the aquarium to hook on, but there is a significant gap between the tubing and the water. the tubes are always filled with fertilizer, so people should keep that in mind if they ever set something like this up!

all in all... maybe around 500 bucks for the pumps and timers. everything else is cheap. and again... 6 independently controlled pumps should be overkill for anyone here. i would assume most people would only dose 2, 3, or 4 different liquids.

JP
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
I always love DIY projects and I'm in the process of making a DIY Dosing pump. I like what you have done, but I don't like the price tag!! ;)

Anyway, have you ever taken a look at the "Tom Aquatics Aqua Lifter—Dosing Pump". You could get those for $15 and put them on a digital time for 1 minute. This would be a lot cheaper!!!

g
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
yeah i didn't like the price tag either, but it has worked out to be pretty good. plus these are fairly heavy duty pumps... i plan on running them for a looooooong time.

i haven't seen the tom's pump thing before (just looked at it). certainly interesting... i never found any decent stuff in my searches so i decided to suck it up and do this. it was a while ago... i was just too lazy to post the pictures up here!

i'd be interested in seeing the durability of these 15-dollar pumps, plus the actual strength (can these push liquid against gravity for 5-ish feet?)... but definitely good for the budget-minded (I know I would have jumped all over them when I was a poor college bum).

thanks for sharing!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
yeah i didn't like the price tag either, but it has worked out to be pretty good. plus these are fairly heavy duty pumps... i plan on running them for a looooooong time.

i haven't seen the tom's pump thing before (just looked at it). certainly interesting... i never found any decent stuff in my searches so i decided to suck it up and do this. it was a while ago... i was just too lazy to post the pictures up here!

i'd be interested in seeing the durability of these 15-dollar pumps, plus the actual strength (can these push liquid against gravity for 5-ish feet?)... but definitely good for the budget-minded (I know I would have jumped all over them when I was a poor college bum).

thanks for sharing!
Yeah, I think those cheap tom's dosing pumps are only rated for 30". I thought I read that somewhere. Head pressure is not as big of an issue for me cause I'm building an all in one inline Heater, CO2 Reactor, Liquid Ferts which will all be under the tank.

I'm actually working on a project that I use an air pump going into a gang value concept. The parts should be coming in this week.

g
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
221 Posts
it's not perfect, pretty, or sexy... but it works! you have no idea how nice it is just knowing that my ferts get dumped in every morning before the lights go on. and the 1/2 gallon jugs hold quite a lot of ferts... so i don't have to fill them very often. the ultimate in low maintenance!
You're a man after my my heart. How long has this been up and running? Any issues, like balancing ferts, or salt build-ups, or hoses cracking, or............?

I had made up my mind to purchase dosers for ferts a few months ago. I do worry about the long term issues. Thanks for the post, this is great!

Oh, the importance is compounded during football season, hunting season, and good enough weather to ride a motorcycle. Maintenance is a hard crew to keep around.;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Why the air gap? I'm setting up a tank with everything coming through bulkheads in the bottom of the tank. Would check valves at the point of introduction to the water stream serve the same purpose?
Those dosing pumps are sort of positive displacement by the cam pinching the hose aren't they? I've got access to a pretty good toy shop at work too and love your set up. Bob
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
so far, it's been up and running for about 2-ish months. it's been solid so far. i just keep tweaking the fert amount. with the independent timers, it's quite easy, so i don't worry about balancing. need more K? run the K pump for 2 more minutes per day. done. And the 1/2 gallon jugs last quite a while (the lowest one is still 1/2 full). so, i'm quite happy with it so far.

obviously, 2 months isn't going to crack and destroy anything yet... the norprene tubing SHOULD last quite a long time, though. i hope. that's the plan at least. and if it doesn't... it will take me 10 minutes to replace all the tubing.

as for the air gap... i did it so the aquarium water (and the microorganisms in it) would not come in contact with a 6-foot tubes of pure fertilizers. i'm pretty sure gunk would start growing and living in the tubes and it would just be bad in general. so now, stuff just "falls" into the water and the tubes stay pure.

as for the idea of a check valve... it SOUNDS ok, but the cautious side of me says no, and here's why: the pumps are extremely slow. i mean, this thing DRIPS ferts into my tank. drip..... drip.... drip... these are IV pumps. so i'm sure the check valves would open and the ferts would go in, but i think there would be some bi-directional flow as soon as the valve opened, because the pressure is just SO low. so i THINK there would still be some sort of back flush. i'm not certain, but it's not something i wanted to test on my system. besides, draping it over the back of the tank really is no big deal. the tubing is very flexible and small. but if you want to give it a go with check-valves, please do and give us feedback!

as for the pumps... the company also sells pumps with controllers built in. so they have the same capabilities of what i "created." however, they were quite a bit more expensive than my 12-dollar table lamp timers. plus my lamp timers have small internal batteries so the settings aren't erased during a power outage (or if i just unplug stuff for fun). so that's a bonus.

anyway, i'm sure there are a few ways of doing this. i know a lot of people here spend so much time perfecting their ferts but then they still dose manually. i just wanted everyone to see that YOU DON'T HAVE TO DO THIS! STOP THE MADNESS!

this was definitely a worth-while project. i am much happier with my aquarium when it doesn't look like a giant maintenance CHORE. i think on my next tank (many years from now), i'm going to build in some sort of an "easy" water-change solution. then i'll reach nirvana.


JP
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
35 Posts
wow, you make some reefers i know look like work-a-holics. haha! very cool set-up, man. now all you need is a robot to bring you beer and you're all set!

-nick
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
I was thinking of diluting the concentrations more, say 10-1 so I could pump more volume to make the metering easier and flush the lines better. I may still give it a try as I just tore down my 26gal bowfront to drill the bottom. If that dosn't work watch for my new 75 gal bowfront!:D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
diluting would work, i guess... it didn't really seem like an option for me. i'm going for super lazy. therefore, i don't want to keep re-filling the reservoirs! heck, i hooked this thing up around xmas and i have only used about 2/3 of my potassium reservoir! so i figure at MOST, i'll have to fill this thing up 4 times per year. that sounds much better to me than filling it 40 times per year :-D

line flush is another interesting idea... i don't know how the lines will behave over time. i guess i'll just find out. SO FAR, no problems though. i really love not dosing daily. i really, really love it.... :)
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
6,406 Posts
Hey great job on the DIY. freemann also has some DIY dosing pumps.

By the way, I can't access the web page for some reason. I keep getting text instead of a page with info. How much were they per pump?

Also, Tom Aquatics Aqua Lifter—Dosing Pump aren't good for dosing. They have nearly no pressure when it comes to liquids. If you were to use them, they'd have to be on the same level as the rim of the tank to pump liquid.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
Hey great job on the DIY. freemann also has some DIY dosing pumps.

By the way, I can't access the web page for some reason. I keep getting text instead of a page with info. How much were they per pump?

Also, Tom Aquatics Aqua Lifter-Dosing Pump aren't good for dosing. They have nearly no pressure when it comes to liquids. If you were to use them, they'd have to be on the same level as the rim of the tank to pump liquid.
This is good to know, I actually was planning on trying them and luckily I'm dosing in-line under the tank so it would be ok. I won't have much head pressure.

g
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts
Great project! I used to use a perastalic for makeup water on a reef tank. It worked very well but I bought too small of tubing and it ran probably 12 hours a day. The plastic around the bearings for the rotor wore out and the pump stopped pumping after about a year. If you can limit the pump run to an hour a day or so by selecting the right size tubing and motor speed they should last long enough to be economical. Thanks for posting!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
345 Posts
Curious about your timer settings and how you have regulated your dosages? How long do you run each pump for and how accurate is each dose? I see you mentioned the tubing used is good for about 0.9ml/min of flow...should I assume then that for a 10ml dose you have your timer set to 11.11111111r minutes??
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
Opps. Sorry, my earlier post was in reference to another post and I was mistaken...

Well after thinking about this, I don't believe it would be a good idea. As the head pressure changes, the amount you dose would change as well...

g
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·
Sorry, haven't been on much to answer questions!

ok, problem number 1 cropped up... the flourish line got clogged! the stuff dried up at the tip after a while and that was the end of that. now i just make sure i look at it once a month to make sure it stays clean. I just poke a paper clip in it to keep it clean. it only crusts up right at the very end, thankfully. i've also started to dose flourish twice a day now... MAYBE that will help it from crusting over so quickly? we'll see. but my lamp timers can have two on/off periods, so why the heck not run it for a few minutes in the afternoon? :)

as for the 0.9ml thing... to be honest, i just guestimated as close as i could. and then when my plants showed signs of deficiencies, i bumped up the time. i kept taking readings to make sure i wasn't poisoning anything. but my nitrates, nitrites, ammonia, and phosphates all stayed low, but present. the nice part about it is that it gets added DAILY (or twice daily if you feel like it). so if you have one or two stem plants that you can watch, you can tweak settings that way. AND on top of that... you always have your water changes to save your butt!

actually, there is one downside i'll mention... it makes you lazy. and mistakes happen when you're lazy. i stopped monitoring the tank for a bit, and the PH dropped. Why? because my KH dropped to nothing! I've never seen it before. i've even gone for like 6 months without water changes on tanks before and never noticed it. suffice it to say, i'm recovering from it.

as for the price of the pumps... brace yourself... i think they were about 70 bucks a piece (ball park). So with 6 pumps, you can see how the price would add up quickly! then again, i think most people would probably use 3 or 4. but then again... there are people on this forum with 200 gallon gardens, and they may consider 500 bucks for a robust auto-doser to be a valuable investment!

i think next time, i may go with larger diameter tubing. the current tubing is fine, but as one member pointed out, the fewer rotations the pump has to make, the better. on the bright side, the tubing that gets squeezed can be easily replaced (and the bearing and roller assembly too, i think). so... when the thing fails in 2 or 4 or 10 years or whatever, i'll happily spend 50 bucks and replace the wearable parts and continue on with life.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
118 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
www.aptinstruments.com is the website. the model i picked up was SP100 FO (fixed output). it's under the OEM pump section. they also sell better-looking ones with housings and stuff, which did not interest me.

as for the in-line dosing... that would be interesting. i considered it, but decided against it BECAUSE... i figured the water in your tank has STUFF in it, and it will grow back into the tube most likely. by having the fertilizer DRIP into the tank, it guarantees that algae and whatever else cannot get into the tube. as i've already found out... a tiny amount of build-up in the tube will block it off, so i'd be wary of that. however, if anyone else actually wants to do an in-line or has already done something like that, please post your feedback!
 
1 - 20 of 97 Posts
Top