Can someone point me to some sort of calculator so I can figure out how to dose my ferts for a DW natural tank. From what I read there will still need to be minor dosing since it is more than likely the bioload won't produce enough food for the plants. I understand that I can not go by the Seachem instructions. I do have minature syringes that can dose small amounts. I have the full line of Seachem fert packs. The tank has been running for 2+ weeks, but I just got my plants in yesterday and packed my 4 gallon real tight. There is a layer of peat underneath my Eco-complete. I only have a Betta in the tank. Once the tank is cycled I am planning on adding more live stock. My guess is 2 Oto's, and maybe some shrimp. Or maybe shrimp and a m/f pair od dario dario's. I would love to add a pygmy cory and an oto but it seems Cories need groups of six or more to thrive....Either way there will be two more small fish in the tank....
DW EL natural fert dosing for 4 gal
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
Hi,
My two cents are that:
Eco-complete + peat is probably not a good mix. Peat is so acidic that it might help release the iron from eco-complete in the water column, which could lead you to algae bloom. From what I remember, Diana had problems with algae when she enriched her soil with laterite (p. 132: "strong acidity and high humus content of the potting soil solubilized massive amounts of iron from the laterite causing iron toxicity to plants").
Why not wait before adding fertilizers? If your plants show specific problems you can address their needs by adding the right fertilizer. From what I've read on this forum, many people having a NPT do not use fertilizers (myself included), but that depends on many factors (type of soil, water hardness, etc.).
Finally, you're right about the cories: they are happier in group
Cheers,
Bart
My two cents are that:
Eco-complete + peat is probably not a good mix. Peat is so acidic that it might help release the iron from eco-complete in the water column, which could lead you to algae bloom. From what I remember, Diana had problems with algae when she enriched her soil with laterite (p. 132: "strong acidity and high humus content of the potting soil solubilized massive amounts of iron from the laterite causing iron toxicity to plants").
Why not wait before adding fertilizers? If your plants show specific problems you can address their needs by adding the right fertilizer. From what I've read on this forum, many people having a NPT do not use fertilizers (myself included), but that depends on many factors (type of soil, water hardness, etc.).
Finally, you're right about the cories: they are happier in group
Cheers,
Bart
I got the peat and Eco methed from Tom Barre's website. I only used 1/4'' instead of the recommended 1''.
That was my feeling on dosing as well. I am guessing in 4-6 weeks I am going to have to dose minute amounts of ferts, since my fishload is going to be tiny.
That was my feeling on dosing as well. I am guessing in 4-6 weeks I am going to have to dose minute amounts of ferts, since my fishload is going to be tiny.
Even if you have a small fishload, you can still add a little more food "for the plants". If you have snails or shrimps, the food will quickly disappear and reappear as snail mulm. With potting soil, I think that food is mainly used to replenish the soil, not as a fertilizer (the soil already contains a lot of nutriments). Others can correct me...
I've read a little about Tom Barr's methods and my first impression was that it was really different than NPTs. One thing I've learned the hard way is that you should not try to mix different methods unless you are ready to experiment a lot and live with the results
I've read a little about Tom Barr's methods and my first impression was that it was really different than NPTs. One thing I've learned the hard way is that you should not try to mix different methods unless you are ready to experiment a lot and live with the results
If you find the plants do need the fertilizers then do the math and cut the recipe down to the recommended dosing for your tank, then cut it in quarters and see if 1/4 of the recommended dose is enough, if not try 50% of what the label suggests.
Fertilizer needs of the plants are variable depending on so many things that it is hard to make predictions or recommendations. Go by what the plants tell you.
Fertilizer needs of the plants are variable depending on so many things that it is hard to make predictions or recommendations. Go by what the plants tell you.
Ok I believe that I am seeing nutrient deficiencies in my nymphoidea aquatica banana plants. Both are showing yellowing of the leaves. They are the only plants showing nutrient deficiencies. Plus for some reason I can not get them to stay planted so they are floating and have grown rhizomes down to the substrate. Its weird but kinda looks cool. So being new to plants should I just dose micro's and if the problem doesn't correct itself add macro's? If I had to guess I would say its a micro problem and not a macro problem. Just a hunch I have after reading a lot.
My second issue is that I am starting to get brown diatom algae on my rotala indica, and bacopa caroliniana but on no other plant including my crypts. I would have thought it was the opposite. The rotala and bacopa would have no algae because they are fast growing? I just did a major trim of the rotala, and bacopa two weeks ago and they both grew back fine. They do need another trim. Though my crypt has doubled in size in a month so what do I know. So not to panic about the algae is this just the normal cycle of a month old tank or is it something else. I do not want to over react, because patience will often times win out. My tank is packed with plants. Though a week ago I took out two java ferns to prepare a new tank for an incoming betta. I am wondering if the removal of those two plants is what caused the delicate balance to swing towards the algae side. And if that is the case maybe I should get some sort of fast growing floating plant to help rebalance the tank. My second course of action if the floater doesn't work is the three day black out, and the final course of action would be to dose excel.
Do these seem like reasonable courses of action? Or should I be thinking about approaching it in a different light?
My second issue is that I am starting to get brown diatom algae on my rotala indica, and bacopa caroliniana but on no other plant including my crypts. I would have thought it was the opposite. The rotala and bacopa would have no algae because they are fast growing? I just did a major trim of the rotala, and bacopa two weeks ago and they both grew back fine. They do need another trim. Though my crypt has doubled in size in a month so what do I know. So not to panic about the algae is this just the normal cycle of a month old tank or is it something else. I do not want to over react, because patience will often times win out. My tank is packed with plants. Though a week ago I took out two java ferns to prepare a new tank for an incoming betta. I am wondering if the removal of those two plants is what caused the delicate balance to swing towards the algae side. And if that is the case maybe I should get some sort of fast growing floating plant to help rebalance the tank. My second course of action if the floater doesn't work is the three day black out, and the final course of action would be to dose excel.
Do these seem like reasonable courses of action? Or should I be thinking about approaching it in a different light?
I only have one oto. He is doing a fine job. Though I think I need a snail to deal with the plant leaves, fish mulm, and whatever leftover food there is.
I also think I need to add more plants. I did a major trimback because it was unsightly. now I have some crypts growing real well, but think some dwarf sag or micro sword would look good planted between them.
I really think I need another tank setup so I can move some plants around and get better proportions going.
I also think I need to add more plants. I did a major trimback because it was unsightly. now I have some crypts growing real well, but think some dwarf sag or micro sword would look good planted between them.
I really think I need another tank setup so I can move some plants around and get better proportions going.
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
Join the discussion
Join now to ask and comment!