[Six]

Without going into extensive details, remember that aquarium fish serve as ambassadors to their wild kin. Without keeping fish and animals in captivity, many wild populations would be disregarded.

The amount of people that care and are proactive about fish and keeping them have achieved much more than I think you know. There are species maintenance programs for endangered goodieds from Mexico as well as care and interest about damning in rivers that hold rare species (such as those being built in China and South America). If we didn't have captive animals, as pets or in zoos, no one would see and therefore learn to care about them and want to help them. Not to mention want to change their lives in order to better strike a balance between us and nature- fish keeping can certainly do all that.

There are some fish who give their lives to the cause.

I used to feel the same way you are. I worked fish retail for 4 years and became fed up with a lot of the customers who just thought fish tanks were "moving pictures", not a responsibility. But I became more involved in the proactive part of the hobby and found myself to feel much better. I'm going to suggest that you do the same. Help others learn about the fish and get them to care. Join a club, go to meetings, speak on a topic. That's part of the reason you joined the forum, isnt it?

 

[Six]

Well, that also comes down to educating the people that sell the fish. We all know pet stores are entry level positions for high school students and those without formal educations (degrees). Trying to get employees involved in clubs is a great idea in my opinion and it helps get more customers into a club and therefore more educated on the fish.

I have to say though, it's a double edged sword for LFS workers. They can join the club, but how many times have you or someone you know ranted about a specific store?
"Those people gave me bad information!"
"That store has so many dead fish, I'm never going back."

Why on earth would someone want to put themselves in that position? To deal with that from angry customers on your off time in a club would be horrible. Considering there are instances in all retail stores where things just don't go well- someone calls off and youre short handed = the fish that die (there always are some) don't get pulled out of tanks and customers judge the store on that single day... it's not really fair. This is why so many people like buying online, they can't see the stuff that is going wrong and therefore think it's a great place. But that's a whole other story...

Anyways, educating people is how to fix the problems you guys are bringing up. Perhaps start a club in your area and try to get members from LFS, employees and customers. It's a lot of work- I'm on the board of my club and it's not easy- but it's worth the effort.

 

[Six]

I see your point and it makes sence but let me think otherwise and the reason I keep thinking this way is that the aquarium trade makes more money from ignorant customers rather than educated ones.

sure, sometimes. also remember that not all newbs listen to lfs or anything anyone else says. sometimes people buy what they want regardless.

The ignorant one will buy air pumps,airstones,gravel cleaners,glass scrapers,plastic plants,algae treatments,resins to lower phosphate and nitrate and lots more.

wait a sec, I buy that stuff. fish breeders use airpumps, and fake plants all the time. those aren't all useless products, they all have some application. you can have different types of aquariums, not all need to be planted display tanks like those on APC.

Have you considered why there is no commercialy available macronutrient supplement in the market? First of all is dangerous for the ignorant...

stores carry what sells. remember most stores HAVE TO cater to newbs and newbs dont buy test kits usually, nor do they buy anything difficult to use. to get people in the hobby you have to sell what sells.
Also, if stores didnt sell items that were dangerous, they would not be allowed to sell antibiotics. Just do a google search on antibiotics and how using meds willy-nilly and dumping them into groundwater sources/sewage can really effect how effective those meds are... bacteria build resistance very quickly- fish meds are not just used for fish.

and second it will prevent the companies from selling all those crap fertilizers they offer.

Not all ferts are crap, some are good to use in addition to dry ferts or for other applications.

In my opinion there will be no such supplement in the market for at least ten more years.Don't tell me about Seachem cause if seachem was manufacturing air pumps and all those other crap it would risk a lot when launching a macronutrient supplement.

I've bought macronutrients online, there are many sites who sell them- are you talking about lfs only??

When the most 'guilty' are huge companies such as tetra,sera and JBL you should not excpect the LFS owner to tell the truth.Go tell a marine biologist who works on one of those companies that you add nitrates to your tank and I bet he will tell you that your nuts.The fact is that he knows your not nuts at all!I had asked someone that question and that was the answear I got.The problem is that if you are in the aquarium trade and want to be competitive you must lie,and that sucks!!

I don't know if I follow this at all. Sure some companies have bad products. JBJ fixtures used to pretty much explode back in the day.
Remember that people at fish stores cannot read your mind as to what you're asking. if you ask for a fert they are likely to "sell" you the one everyone else buys. are you saying they sell you the most expensive item?

this conversation turned into a debate about dry goods- I thought we were talking about live animals.... either way, those are my experiences. If you dwell on the negative, you're going to be unhappy regardless.

I agree- half full.

 

[Six]

I agree, saving only the pretty ones will get us no where with my previous reasoning- but validating the life of an ugly fish through admiration for it in a captive setting first is a start.

Regardless, people have to SEE a fish to care if it lives- in the wild or captivity.

Sure, we overdid it with galaxy rasbora and roselines, but that's not to say there aren't good reasons now to protect the areas they live. I agree whole heartedly that protecting the areas fish live is the best way to protect fish- but you cannot protect all river ways, some have to be used especially in developing countries. If people do not know the fish, something they can use to sell/breed/eat exist they won't protect the areas. So which comes first? Protecting all areas as a premtive measure? Or figuring out which fish/animals need it the most and doing it then?