Aquatic Plant Forum banner

Lifebearers and planted tanks.

1 reading
1.4K views 5 replies 6 participants last post by  John N.  
#1 ·
I've observed that most planted tanks in the hobby are occupied by fish like tetras, algae eatting shrimps and otocinclus. I too once has a tank like this. But one day, a decided to add a few platies and guppies into the tank to feed on surface scum, to my surprise, not only did they clean up surface scum, I've observed them diligently cleaning all sorts of algae off my plant leaves. I can actually see the algae getting plucked off the anubias leave and disappear into their mouths. I even saw them feeding on the notoriously STINKY BGA. In fact, I feel that they are much more efficient than shrimps and even otos. Well its just a feeling. ;)

It is also very interesting to watch them peck at the leaves of plants. Few fish actually will "interact" with plants this way. Their colours are quite attractive for a member of the algae crew too! Perhaps its because livebearers are such prolific breeders and their low value have caused their demise in the popularity within the planted tank community. By the way, the platies I'm using are feeder platies. Just 50¢ and I get a whole bag full of them.

I'm glad that they are now part of my "algae crew" and they are definitely here to stay in my tank. What are your views about lifebearers?
 
#2 ·
I have mostly guppies in my tank - beautiful fish even in the 2nd generation. They do seem to eat algae off the plants, but not nearly enough to clean off the algae. I have also kept platys and mollies, which were also very enjoyable. For me the fish are secondary to the plants, there to add more interest to the tank, and live bearers add the most interest.
 
#3 ·
I'm a big fan of livebearers for the same reason folks don't like them. They breed profusely, so I don't worry about having to re-populate tanks and then having to worry about quarantining or introduced diseases/parasites from the lfs. Now, if I could only get my panda cories to take a lesson from my guppies in the game of love... :)
 
#4 ·
I have swordtails in my tank and they are my favorite fish. They do pick at stuff in the plants like you discribed, but don't have a huge effect on the algae. I have noticed too that they do interact with the plants a lot more than the tetras or danios. One of them has a favorite Anubias leaf that it likes to hid under, and another younger fish likes to hide in my dense mass of vall.
 
#5 ·
I myself think livebeares look great in a planted tank, but there are some that do not for one reason or another. I like that they come in such a wide range of colors/shapes and are prolific breeders. Funny thing is at the moment I do not have any. But in the past I have kept Guppies, Mollies, Platys & Endlers. One day I would like to have a planted tank dedicated to livebearers.
 
#6 ·
I do enjoy livebearers, but unforutunately can't house them typically with shrimp unless I want to treat the livebears real well with snacks :( But I do have one tank dedicated to Endlers.

Besides the shrimp though, the reason why I avoid getting livebears is because they distract from the aquacape sometimes with their rapid movements, and swimming in every which directions. I think people enjoy the schooling aspects of tetras, and the algae eating benifits of otos.

-John N.