Aquatic Plant Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,552 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
With the ADA contest deadline past and folks gearing up for being inside more as winter is nigh you may have noticed more and more posts where others are doing some tank clearing in order to change aquascapes and are giving away plants for a little more then the price of shipping. Being one that is giving plants away I've noticed certain things that well, frankly are annoying.

In no particular order and with in a attempt to be at least mildly humorous...

<sarcasim>
Shipping costs: The majority of folks in the US ship via USPS Priority Mail. It cost $3.85 for the first 1 lb anywhere in the US. So why do people charge $5? I no longer count how many people that accuse me of profiteering saying I am making a whopping $1.15 per order. Lets take an honest look at costs.

$5.00 Sent to shipper via PayPal
-$0.15 PayPal charges 2.9% of the total
-$0.30 PayPal also charges 0.30 per transaction, be it 0.01 or 99999.99
=$4.55
-$3.85 Priority Mail Shipping Charge
=$0.70

Of the 70 cents the shipper needs to have certain supplies on hand, namely Paper towels and Ziploc type bags as well as paper and ink for the printer to print mailing labels and fuel costs to get to/from post office. So in the end the Shipper walks away with maybe 30 cents. Time and effort is not factored in as it's a hobby and if I was not willing to spend the time I would not offer the plants. For the sake of argument, lets say I send out 10 boxes at a time. That's $3.00, not exactly get rich quick material.

Will you ship to (insert foreign country here)? If the post says " I live in East Timor and will only ship to others in East Timor" than by golly, no I'm not shipping to Canada. Why is this you ask. The reasons are many: a. Shipping live plants across borders may be illegal. b. PayPal charges yet even more to convert from your currency to mine. c. Shipping costs are exponentially higher d. shipping times are exponentially longer e. it's a pain in the @ss to fill out all those customs papers f. there is a good chance your plants will be "disposed of properly" by the authorities. (Picture a gov't contractor in a clean suit tossing the plants into an incinerator)

Please send ALL of it to me as I have started a 10gal tank and need to fill it. That's one of my favorites, cause IF one took the time to look at the amounts being given away one would see that ALL the plants offered would fill a 10gal leaving no room for water or fish or snails or substrate. That request goes hand in hand with&#8230;.

My tank has X wpg and Y water conditions, can you tell me if your plants will work, and where should I put them with Q mix of plants? No offense folks but I'm giving away plants, not designing your aquascape. There is TONS of info on this as well as other boards that describe what the plant needs, where it will fit in your overall design and if it will even fit in your tank. There are books that also have this info. Do some research, you might learn something.

Payment: When the shipper says "PayPal only" it does not mean "PayPal for everyone but you". No, I don't take checks. Money Orders, your first born or Food Stamps. Also this echeck thing that PayPal offers is not really acceptable, it takes 4-5 business days for the funds to clear and by then most of us offering plants up have already shipped and take the risk that your $5 echeck may bounce. Yeah I know it's only $5 and the money is not the point, but for those of us turn around and pay the shipping from PayPal it adds an extra layer of complexity.

I know you said you will ship on Xday but my lights are not here yet or the tank has no water yet or anything like that, so will you ship to me some other time please? All I can say here is "if you are not ready then wtf are you asking for plants!!"

Hopefully I've done a fine job at this point of offending everyone that makes me wonder why the heck I even bother offering plants instead of tossing them on the compost heap and you have seen the error of your ways.
</sarcasim>

For those of you that offer up plants, I hope you too found this funny.

Lastly for those of you that don't make it a chore to offer free plants, I THANK YOU!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
852 Posts
LOLOLOLOLOL

"Despite the fact that auction clearly stated 'Will ship to United States only', the Korean woman bit her lip and pressed the Submit button. Her $40.00 bid appeared on the screen. She was going have her Downoi if it cost her the world."

Yeah, big problem. And I don't see why anyone has a right to complain about a $5 S/H cost. I don't know about you, but my Post Office isn't exactly within walking distance. And Ziploc bags, for what they are, aren't cheap. Not to mention all the chemicals, electricity, and water used to actually grow the plants. Come to think of it, once you factor in everything you spend, the $5 is probably less than what it costs to get that plant to the bidder, which means if you're giving away plants for free, you're taking a little bit of a hit.

My personal favorites are the ones who e-mail you after the auction has ended and say, "Dude, my bid on your Cyperus didn't win. Can I just PayPal you what I bid for it and you can send me a little? Just maybe a runner...?"

Uhhh...no. I would've posted multiple auctions if I had multiple items to sell. If you want the plant, bid higher or get it elsewhere. Sorry!

And the ones who want to buy directly from you for what the auction price BEGAN as. No, really. This has happened to me SEVERAL times.

Add all of this up to the fact that most of us throw in extras to offset shipping and other costs. I can't count the number of times I've thrown in substantial portions of "uncommon" species and had actual COMPLAINTS about the selection. They're FREE, people. FREE. Beggers can't be chosers. If I send you free M. mattogrossense, I've just saved you the time and money it would've taken to haggle over it on Aquabid. So DO NOT e-mail me asking for my Pantanal or HC.

Oh, I almost forgot. Non-responsive bidders/takers. If you're going to express some interest in my plants, the last thing you should do is ignore your e-mail or give me an e-mail address that filters out my replies. And please...if I e-mail you asking for information...don't put off replying! Many of us have schedules to keep.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,130 Posts
A great read, both of you! I totally agree. $5 for shipping is really taking a knife and stabbing it into your own chest. Then why do people still feel anal about it and hassle us? I don't know~ Good job at breaking it down, gnat.

As for those trying to buy off the auction at initial bid, what would be whole point of auctioning if you can already get the plants at lower cost? That is why I always pay much more than the winning bid, or at least the same provided the seller has extras and doesn't mind selling them. This only happens when I really absolutely gotta have the plants and I couldn't possibly find it elsewhere. The key point is: always ask and communicate effectively first!!! Either by e-mail or by phone call to speak with the seller. Get to know them to develop that level of trust. Finally, it is a sorta unofficial rule to show off your professional courtesy and mannerism. Like Error said, if you are getting the plants for free or really low price then please be a gentlemen or lady and maybe even offer a little extra money. It's just one of those small gestures that will get you far~ Well, at least it's still not as far as if you have to travel to the Far East and get those plants yourself! Kindda think about it;) I can relate and understand all your points as I am both a seller and a buyer. Lastly, we are all people with similar or same hobbies, and it will do us all good to be nice and courteous to one another. Make friends will get you a long way. Make enemies....well, then I guess the Administrator wouldn't even allow you to be in this forum, haha:p

Paul
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,035 Posts
In my opinion, I always offer a price which is inclusive of mailing. That way people simply bid or not bid according to their budget. Having to email several times to establish the mailing charge is irritating for me as both buyer and seller (long time seller on eBay I might add).

As for Aquabid, I love it. I would even support it financially. But if only Aquabid would include a flat price sales system - eBay calls it Buy It Now. Time would be saved all round. Auctioning items for under $10.00 just does not seem worth it when time is short.

I also empathize with the points expressed above.

Andrew Cribb
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,988 Posts
Excellent post Gnatster and wonderful pionts that I think most would not have realized unless they stopped to think about it.

Another point I might add, if I may, is often when I send plants, especially stems, I find they don't often fit unthe small box, so what do I do... I use the big one. What is the base price to ship that? $4.65. Well, considering that i have to drive 7miles round trip and my big gas guzzling 4x4 gets 15mpg city, thats .93c in gas. Whoops! more than the $5 already, plus 1-3, often use the gallon size, bags. What are they, $3-4 for a box of 20, thats 15-20 cents each.....

As Gnat already pointed out, we are trying to be NICE:)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26 Posts
Thanks

I want to say thanks to all who offer free plants, and also thanks to the ones who have sent me plants, I do appriciate all. I can not afford to buy alot at a time. I am out on disability but I love my fish and I love plants and if there are nice enough people to charge a little for the plants and shipping , they are great in my book. I love you all.. I think the ones on this board are the greatest. Again, thank YOU< JO Ann :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
628 Posts
I agree 100% as a buyer and seller...and one note for aquabid sellers....please DON'T ship stem plants by standard mail.... :roll:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,920 Posts
My trip to the post office is 20 minutes to a half hour each way (usually half hour)! Approx 20 miles I think (never checked the odometer) -- so when I offer plants for free it is definitely a labor of love. Someone started me off on plants that way, and I tried very hard to do the same for others. However, that post office trip with two jobs just isn't my cup of tea. I've offered for sale once, and may start doing that more b/c sending out plants can basically take up my whole morning (trimming, packaging, labeling, trip to post office).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
426 Posts
USPS shipping supplies can be ordered for free. Stamped mailing labels can be printed from home/work. There is also no need to stop by the postal office because you can arrange for home pick-up of items that won't fit in your mailbox (free service). You don't even have to be home for that. Just jam them behind some bushes, bury them in the yard, or tie them to a tree. Just describe the location of where you hid the oversized items and the nice USPS post(wo)man will get off his/her truck and retrieve them.

Paper towels may be obtained from fastfood restaurants, work, etc. Grocery bags can be employed to house the plants. Miscellaneous advertisements, community newspapers, etc. may be used for extra insulation and modes to prevent the shifting of plants during shipping.

You folks need to be more resourceful. :mrgreen:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,448 Posts
Excellent points Gnat, Error and Paul! I agree completely. For most of us this is a labor of love and not a business. How many businesses would survive making .25 - .50 cents per transaction after going through all the work it takes? Some people just need a reality check.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
389 Posts
Wow! 20-30 minutes by car to the closest post office :shock: ?! Takes me 5 minutes to *walk* to mine, and I'm so lazy, I drive to it :lol: ! But yes, I got a good chuckle from this thread :wink: ... Not that I encounter these people too often, thank goodness.

Actually, I don't give away my plants very often because I can't grow much of anything really well :oops: . But I pick up rare plants from the LFS for people all the time, and I only ask for actual reimbursement: cost of plants, tax, shipping, delivery confirmation (if requested) and if paying by PayPal, then 3% of grand total plus $0.30. Sometimes, I worry that those plants won't arrive in good condition, so I'll offer up some of my own plants that I need to prune, anyway. I'm content just to get reimbursed, but often, I'll get people who are SO generous! Some people tack on a significant extra, and I've had a few people actually show their gratitude by sending some beautiful clippings from their own tanks! I feel terrible because I end up killing most of them, but I'm deeply touched by the sentiment O:) . Today, one person (you know who you are :wink: ) even offered to send some fish I've been wanting! Another person (you know who *you* are) even offered to send me some of his very rare, very slow-growing plant for free (a tiny plant that I paid $15 for at my LFS)!

So I guess if you look at it another way (and you're willing [and can afford] to put up with some of the more "annoying" instances), it all pretty much evens out. I've met so many nice people who make me wish that I didn't have to ask for reimbursement at all.

But on the downside, yes, if you're a busy person, it can be a PITA to trim, wrap, bag, box, label, and make the trip to the P.O. (and let's not forget those times when there's only one person working the window and a half-dozen people in front of you who each take like 15 minutes...) and I can see the pettiness in somebody complaining about paying $5 as opposed to $3.85. I think that if/when they progress in the hobby, they'll better understand the fact that they got a very nice deal. You'd be paying a whole lot more at a LFS for much less and poorer quality. Home-grown stuff from avid hobbyists can't be beat 8) . People eventually figure this out. We should also keep in mind that we have some people in the hobby who are teenagers - high school or college students on a very tight budget and sometimes can't get PayPal accounts even if they wanted to. And they have to justify the purchase to their parents just to get them to write a $5 check. Hopefully, one day when they're growing tons of plants in their first high-tech tank that they were able to afford after getting their first decent-paying job, they'll remember the generosity of an experienced hobbyist who basically got them started with their first planted tank for the cost of shipping, and they'll turn around and do the same for another budding aquatic gardener ;).

-Naomi
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
302 Posts
Great topic...Gnomes circumstance is pretty similar to how I got to a planted tank.

As far as I'm concerned-they all grow very well, but I ain't all that good at aquascaping :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
628 Posts
great post Naomi!

You definitely can meet some nice people if you take the time, sometimes people are just young or first starting out and eventually you might find them helping you out!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,920 Posts
Interesting CS -- but my post people don't even come down my street. My mailbox is on the main road and if a package doesn't fit, they strap it to the box with the lid down.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
281 Posts
Your sarcasm rocks Gnatster ;)

I know you said you will ship on Xday but my lights are not here yet or the tank has no water yet or anything like that, so will you ship to me some other time please? All I can say here is "if you are not ready then wtf are you asking for plants!!"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
63 Posts
MY post office charges $4.05 for the first lb Priority shipping. Then another $.50 for delivery confirmation. how come yours is $3.85??????
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,552 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
Because when I wrote that the cost was $3.85, since then there was an increase to $4.05. Delivery confirmation is free if one purchases and prints postage from home.
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top