Posts by BryceM
1 - 4 of 76 Posts
Joined
·
4,333 Posts
OK. This thread (like any other) will be closed if civil conversation can't take place here. It would really be a shame, since there is certainly value in discussing an agent that might posses some beneficial anti-algae properties.
Look, constructive and useful discussion in an open forum can only take place within a framework of mutual respect. One can emphatically disagree with someones position without resorting to a personal attack. The best way to do this is to present evidence to support one's position.
Edward's argument (potential harm to animals) is poorly presented, but does raise a valid concern. With more careful wording, it might have encouraged a healthy discussion about the potential toxic effects rather inciting an emotionally charged exchange. We should all keep in mind that a remedy at one concentration is often a poison at another.
I happen to agree with Cavan's argument that we should all be focusing on providing conditions that don't favor the growth of algae. Even so, it doesn't hurt to investigate the benefits and limitations of a potential algicide. I frequently use a short course of Excel or erythromycin to restore things to a stable, healthy condition.
Look, constructive and useful discussion in an open forum can only take place within a framework of mutual respect. One can emphatically disagree with someones position without resorting to a personal attack. The best way to do this is to present evidence to support one's position.
Edward's argument (potential harm to animals) is poorly presented, but does raise a valid concern. With more careful wording, it might have encouraged a healthy discussion about the potential toxic effects rather inciting an emotionally charged exchange. We should all keep in mind that a remedy at one concentration is often a poison at another.
I happen to agree with Cavan's argument that we should all be focusing on providing conditions that don't favor the growth of algae. Even so, it doesn't hurt to investigate the benefits and limitations of a potential algicide. I frequently use a short course of Excel or erythromycin to restore things to a stable, healthy condition.
Joined
·
4,333 Posts
Hoppy sent me a message indicating that because of the content of this thread, he would now be devoting his time on other forums.
I'm certainly not singling anyone out here. I suspect Hoppy's declining activity here goes way beyond this thread. It does serve as a critical reminder to all of us that written text is often far more blunt, and therefore more hurtful, than would ever be conveyed during the same conversation in person.
The written nature of forums leads to misunderstandings with regrettable frequency.
Joined
·
4,333 Posts
Manwithnoalgae,
Most people who have messed around with algae problems are closer to success than they realize. There isn't a single formula for success but there are a few simple principles and if you'll follow them, I can almost guarantee success. Send me a PM.
Most people who have messed around with algae problems are closer to success than they realize. There isn't a single formula for success but there are a few simple principles and if you'll follow them, I can almost guarantee success. Send me a PM.
1 - 4 of 76 Posts
