Aquatic Plant Forum banner

My first Walstad Tank

2.5K views 11 replies 5 participants last post by  Zer00  
#1 ·
Image

Its a 10g aquarium.
Soil is Miracle Grow Organic Soil.
The sand cap is Quikrete Pool Filter Sand
Plants:
Hornwort, ludwegia repens, bacopa, pygmy chain swords, and temple plant.
I plan to add floating plants later.
Is it enough plants to start?
What are your thoughts?
What could make it better?
 
#5 ·
Nice start! It looks like this photo was taken just after you planted it. Some of the stem plants have not straightened up yet.

This may be nitpicking, but I would remove the surface scum. Just take a cup and scoop up the surface layer.

It's now up to the plants!
Thanks for the reply @dwalstad.
I will get rid of that surface scum.
And you are right on. The pic was taken literally right after planting. :)
 
#6 ·
This is a beautiful aquarium!

My $0.02 - if I was to change anything about this, it would be purely for aesthetic purposes.
You might consider adding a small / dense carpeting plant, like Pearl Weed - to help visually blend the chain swords with the larger stems in the background.
Again - purely aesthetic - this is a really great start.

Looking forward to seeing updates as this progresses!
 
#8 ·
Looks great! Do I see pearling on the Cabomba/hornwort? Red stem plants have shot up from earlier photo.
One suggestion--or consideration. The front unplanted area probably needs to be poked to bring in oxygen and release gasses. I notice that your small rosette plants there have not grown.
That said, you could just let things be. The front area with soil is probably loading the tank up with CO2 and nutrients. Fortunately, though, you have enough good growers in the back to enjoy the resulting feast.
 
#9 ·
Looks great! Do I see pearling on the Cabomba/hornwort? Red stem plants have shot up from earlier photo.
One suggestion--or consideration. The front unplanted area probably needs to be poked to bring in oxygen and release gasses. I notice that your small rosette plants there have not grown.
That said, you could just let things be. The front area with soil is probably loading the tank up with CO2 and nutrients. Fortunately, though, you have enough good growers in the back to enjoy the resulting feast.
Thanks!
Yep, they are pearling a bit!
There are some diatoms. Will this go away as the tank continues to stabilize?
I will poke some holes in the substrate.